| THE INTERNATIONAL|
DUKE ELLINGTON MUSIC SOCIETY
04/2 August-November 2004
FOUNDER: BENNY AASLAND
Voort 18b, 2328 Meerle, Belgium
Telephone: +32 3 315 75 83
Blue Bells or Blue Belles of Harlem ?
See DEMS 04/1-17
Steven Lasker has sent us a photocopy of page 1242 of the Catalog of Copyright Entries - Musical Compositions. Entry 29343 reads as follows:
Blue belles of Harlem ; melody Duke Ellington. © 1 c. Oct.3, 1940 ; E unp. 233240 ; Robbins music corp., New York.
On the ASCAP list (which was the source for the list in MIMM) the title is spelled: Blue Bells of Harlem. It seems that we should accept both spellings. See for the story behind this composition the Paul Whiteman initiative for staging another "Experiment in Modern Music" at Carnegie as described in Stratemann p156. "Six composers - Ellington among them - had been commissioned to contribute to a 40-minute musical anthology titled 'Those Bells' ".
I'm sure we can simply take Blue Belles of Harlem as a punning title of the sort we know Duke loved. Maybe the first entry was made closer to the date of the original Whiteman 'Bells' commission and that the later one reflects Duke's play on the word. Am I right in thinking that, once Ellington started performing his piece himself, away from the context of the Whiteman commission in 1938, the word was always spelled Belles, as on the concert programme for 23 January 1943, and never went back to Bells?
Duke Ellington Live at Carnegie Hall - 11Dec43
I have only recently come across a copy of DEMS Bulletin 02/1in which there was a review of a Duke Ellington Live at Carnegie Hall 11Dec43 Concert on p19/1.
Since I was the founder back in the early 60s of Ember Records and your critic took time out to berate me about the poor and incorrect liner notes, I thought that I would at least come back to you with some comments which may be beneficial to all concerned.
I accept that I am not a writer but I am a devoted fan of the Duke and had the pleasure of knowing him and seeing many performances of the Band.
It was my love of Jazz music that not only prompted the founding of The Flamingo Jazz Club in London which I launched back in 1951 and which helped to encourage the growth of British Jazz but because of the love of the Duke's music, I also acquired material and released it on my Ember label.
The re-release on EMBCD507 via our then distributor, TKO Magnum Music was obviously a less than satisfactory release from the point of view of the hierarchy of the Duke Ellington Music Society but it was an honest endeavour to put back on the market an album that had been well received in its original vinyl form. The notes were written with the best intention and were the honest intent of being informative. I apologise to all and sundry if these notes were incorrect and certainly make no apology for the "poor notes" but then I am not an expert.
Since I have obviously made some major errors and having apologised for these omissions, I would like to suggest that since Ember Records still has in its vaults many tracks of Duke Ellington, that we solicit the help of the Duke Ellington Music Society through your goodself in asking your help. From all the titles that we do have in the catalogue, would Mr Steiner and/or other members of the Society be prepared to work with us on the putting together of some definitive Ellington re-releases of material we originally released on vinyl but this time with absolute perfection to have definitive notes and personnel so we correct and amend the previously well intentioned but not well received at the Society level of our endeavours.
This is a genuine effort to solicit your help and I accept the rebukes in the spirit that they were written but nevertheless we did at least get the record back on to the market and I know it has given pleasure to many fans from the countless letters we have received in which many of them were not so scathing as that received at the hands of your colleagues.
I do hope to hear from you.
Dr Jeffrey Kruger - MBE, Founder - Ember Records
It is obvious that we welcome every release of Ellington recordings. Many "old" collectors would love to see some "fresh" material released before they have to give up collecting and there is still a small but very dedicated group of young collectors, who would benefit from re-releases.
We gladly offer you our assistance in every respect. We certainly are more than happy to check your liner-notes beforehand and to mention your new or re-releases in our Bulletin. We wish you good-luck!
It is a shame that Jeff Kruger has been upset by comments in the Bulletin on his Ember re-release of the second Carnegie Hall concert recordings, especially as I know he has played a distinguished part in the growth of jazz in Britain. I bought the 'Historically Speaking' LP and the 1946 Musicrafts on his Ember LPs many years ago and found them very acceptable despite the sketchy notes. It was exactly such notes on many LP issues in the 60s and 70s which led me to start digging into the facts behind the recordings in the first place, and so brought me eventually to the Bulletin! We have learned so much more over 30-40 years, and the musical landscape is now so vast, that no one can keep up with everything. Generalists need to know how to contact others who specialise, so they can use the specialists' expertise. A straight CD reissue of an LP, which appeared 30 years ago, is a risky project, unless the content of the LP was very thoroughly researched in the first place. And even in those cases it is likely that updating will be needed. If some good comes of this upset, in the shape of well-presented issues of other material not currently available (or poorly compiled), I shall be pleased.
See DEMS 04/1-1
Nell Brookshire was born 26Sep39 and died 27Dec03.
The BBC America Dances Story
See DEMS 04/1-6
The correct location of the 15Mar39 session was the CBS Studios in NYC, John Harper announcer. The sequence of the titles is correct apart from the fact that Pussy Willow does not appear in the BBC listings or the review of the broadcast in "The Melody Maker" of 25Mar39 p4. The program was heard in England between 7:02:45 - 7:30 PM local time.
You are right. The location of the 15Mar39 broadcast was not the Apollo Theatre but the CBS Studios (as correctly mentioned in the New DESOR). I made the mistake myself.
Closing Night at the Hotel Sherman
There's an NBC broadcast surviving from the last night of Duke's Sherman Hotel residency in Chicago in summer 1942, 13Aug. There's a discrepancy between the content of this broadcast as described in the New DESOR, and as described in Timner (4th ed) and Nielsen. The New DESOR says Ivie sings Massachusetts. Nielsen and Timner say she sings At Last and Be Careful It's My Heart.
Can you tell me who's right?
In order to be consistent, the New DESOR should have included only three selections from this session, Manhattan Serenade; At Last andMassachusetts. Only these three selections have been listened to and described by Giovanni and Luciano. They do not have a copy of the other tunes, neither do I nor anybody I know or knew like the late Benny Aasland, who not only included all eight titles in WaxWorks 42-33, but also mentioned the soloists. Timner and Nielsen copied Benny Aasland's mistakes from WaxWorks (1979). The Italians have trusted Benny Aasland only as far as the titles were concerned. They have not accepted the soloists and they are right not to do so. I can confirm that At Last is an instrumental piece without vocal and that Massachusetts was sung by Ivie, because I have listened to the recordings as found by Jerry Valburn in 1985, see DEMS 85/3-4. I should have mentioned this in my Comments on Timner, but I have not paid much attention to the initials of the vocalists.
The European tour in 1950
See DEMS 04/1-21
A comment regarding Horst Bergmeier's questions about the 1950 European tour. In Sweden, there were only 2 trombones (LB and QJ) but 6 saxes. Alva McCain played the third trombone part on tenor. This is a parallel to 1969, at least in Sweden, when Norris Turney did the same thing.
Al Hibbler on It Don't Mean a Thing
I have recently purchased a 78rpm record that is puzzling me. The label is "Blue Bell" N.Y. 537. The artist is Al Hibbler and The Boys. The music is on side A: It Don't Mean a Thing - part I. On the other side is part II and it is only filling 50 percent of the space. The record is not listed in Jerry Valburn's Directory of DE Recordings.
"The Boys" are unmistakably Duke Ellington's Orchestra.
From the New DESOR, I can tell that Al Hibbler performed It Don't Mean a Thing on 4 occasions: Carnegie Hall, 26 and 27Dec47 and Click Restaurant, 24Nov48 and 2Sep49. The Click Restaurant performances have been issued on Raretone 5003 and 5005 respectively while the first two remain unissued. Do you have any information about this Blue Bell record ?
I cannot believe that your 78rpm record is from any of the four Ellington dates you mentioned. It wouldn't have been a 78rpm but a track on an LP. It might be the recording from 1948/49, Chicago, Al Hibbler and the Ellingtonians, matrix Su2135, released on Chess, as mentioned in Timner (4th edition) on page 471. Although it seems that this Chess 78rpm had on the flip side another title (What Will I Tell My Heart?) and not part II of It Don't Mean a Thing. Furthermore, you say that it was Ellington's orchestra. However on the Chess 78rpm is only a small group: Ray Nance, Tyree Glenn, Ben Webster, Billy Strayhorn, Junior Raglin and Fletcher Jackson. As you understand, I do not have a copy of the Blue Bell 78rpm you mentioned. If you make me a copy (on cassette if you wish) I will be happy to compare it with all the Hibbler performances of this title that I have. Do you hear an audience?
No, it cannot be the Chess recording because there is the full band behind Hibbler. Having listened to the recording again several times I think it can after all be one of the Raretone recordings but I am unable to tell which one. I hear no audience. I will send you a copy on cassette. You will notice that the tune is running for a little more than 4 minutes and therefore they have split it over the two sides. At the end of side 1 they are fading down the music to a close and starting it up on side 2 with a fade up.
Thank you very much for the copy on cassette. What you have on the mysterious 78rpm "Blue Bell" is a part (4 min) of the 24Nov48 (6 min) recording. "Blue Bell" ends in the 5° chorus at bar 28. The 5° and 6° choruses are not by Ben Webster as mistakenly claimed on the jacket of the Raretone LP 5003. It is Al Sears. The Raretone recording is also not complete. It ends in the 7° chorus at bar 16. Those who want absolutely to know which one was the very first release should make a note. Your "Blue Bell" 78rpm is undoubtedly older than the 1979 Raretone LP and could as such be considered a collector's item.
The six important Columbia/Legacy releases
See DEMS 03/3-20/4
I have found in Antwerp's FNAC the CD "Festival Session" with the number 512916 2, the CD "Ellington Uptown" with the number 512917 2 and the CD "Masterpieces by Ellington" with the number 512918 2. On these CDs is mentioned "made in Austria". These numbers are different from the numbers mentioned in DEMS 03/2-21 and 22 where the numbers were respectively CK 87044, CK 87066 and CK 87043. The numbers differ but the CDs are identical.
Georges Debroe has not exaggerated. Patricia Willard's liner-notes are indeed brilliant. She has interviewed long ago and also quite recently, everybody who could give her more insight in the sessions and she came forward with some highly interesting and "fresh" information. It is with the greatest respect that I make some remarks and ask some questions. Not to be critical but only to be helpful in setting straight some minor details.
It is suggested in the liner notes that Willie Cook who played in the Festival Session, sailed (or flew) with the band to Europe (Sep59) and that he would move on from the band within the year. As far as we know, Willie Cook did not join the band which went to Europe. There are no reports or video recordings which show us five trumpet-players in all.
Clark Terry's feature Juniflip on the Flugelhorn was actually first recorded at Travis Air Force Base on 4Mar58.
We found the following statement on page 3 below the personnel listing rather cryptic: "When only one drummer is playing, it is Sam Woodyard". This cannot be the case for DUAEL FUEL. On this piece we clearly hear a single drummer from time to time, but it is not Sam, it is Jimmy Johnson. It seems that the statement was intended to indicate that there was only one drummer on the other selections on this album, but that is not the case either, because we hear two drummers on IDIOM'59, specifically in part 3. If the right and the left channels are in place, we can state that the high hat (which came through the right channel) was played by Sam Woodyard.
It is untrue that Launching Pad was until now erroneously credited exclusively to Ellington as claimed in the liner notes. It was as early as 1977 credited to both Ellington and Terry in the old Desor. Eddie Lambert also knew what he was talking about (p216) when he wrote long ago (anyway before 1987) that Launching Pad was probably written as a collaboration between Ellington and Terry. On my Columbia LPs no composers are mentioned and on my old Columbia CD 468402 it is indeed only attributed to Ellington, but on my Philips LP 840 074, which I bought in 1961 it reads on the label Launching pad [sic] (Ellington/Terry). The concert version of 4Jul59 at Newport has been issued on a Foxy double LP, which correctly credits Ellington-Terry. Moreover, in the concert itself Duke credits Clark Terry: "And now another new number. Clark Terry brought in a thing we are gonna call it, it is supposed to be in the middle of a suite, but we're gonna call it Launching Pad. Are you ready? Shall we count down?" I have no idea why Duke transferred the solo part in Launching Pad from Harold Baker to Ray Nance. Harold performed it at Newport on 4Jul59 and again at the Playboy Festival on 8Aug59, a month before the studio session. In my humble opinion he did at Newport an even better job than Ray. We cannot tell you how he sounded on the Playboy recording because Harold's mike was switched off. Duke again credited Clark as follows (one word could not be understood): "And now a new thing [unidentified word] Clark Terry, called Launching Pad. You know what a launching pad is? Everyone has a pad, but it is only a launching pad when it gets you some place." After the number Duke called: "Clark Terry, Shorty Baker. Thank you very much for Launching Pad."
It is indeed a pity that Clark never did the solo part. It would have been interesting to hear his version.
1. Skin Deep. On page 7 we read that Sonny Greer rendered the final bar of Skin Deep. Must we take that literally? In that case, he should be included in the list of personnel in our discographies. In defence of numerically-bound discographers, I point out that the wrong date for the recording of Skin Deep was supplied by Columbia on CK 40836 as 8Dec52. Since the matrix number did not make sense, the DESOR group presumed that this was again the mix-up of dates between the American and the European way of presenting dates and they changed the date in Benny Aasland's Waxworks from 10Aug52 into 12Aug52. In the new DESOR the date was changed into 8Nov52, which was quite reasonable since that was the date of the Mercer session from which Columbia acquired on 8Dec52 two selections (Good Woman Blues and Body and Soul) in addition to the Mercer recording of Skin Deep. This explains at the same time the wrong recording date of 8Dec52 mentioned by Columbia. I understand that discographers are reluctant to bother the soloist or the record producer in person. What they prefer to do is inquire at the office of the record company, which usually doesn't bother to send an answer.
2. The Mooche. The sequence of the soloists seems to be wrong. The New DESOR has indeed first Hilton Jefferson (in the 4° and 5° chorus) before Harry Carney (in the 6° chorus) but this description was corrected in DEMS Bulletin 02/2-27 (page 1213) by Hans-Joachim Schmidt who wrote: "The description is wrong in that it is definitely Paul Gonsalves on tenor behind Quentin Jackson in the 4° and 5° chorus, not Hilton Jefferson on alto. Paul plays the role of Johnny Hodges (later Willie Smith) here, and Hilton Jefferson is 'recompensed' with an extra solo afterwards." (Hilton's solo is in the 7° chorus).
3. Take the "A" Train. I have tried to find any of the "most discographies", in which it is claimed that Billy Strayhorn played the piano. No such claim is made either in the old Desor, or in the New DESOR, or in Nielsen, Lord, Jepsen, Lambert or Timner's 1st, 2nd or 3rd edition. Only in Timner's 4th edition is Billy mentioned among the personnel of this session, but even here he is not specifically credited for playing Take the "A" Train. All discographers agree with Clark Terry (and so do I): Duke was on the piano.
4. Harlem was indeed premiered at the Metropolitan Opera House on 21Jan51, but not with a symphony orchestra. The premiere with the NBC Symphony Orchestra was on 20Jun51 at the Lewisohn Stadium in NYC. See Klaus Stratemann p327. The performance of 21Jan51 was recorded and has been released on Rare Records LP 3. The 20Jun51 performance was either not recorded or the recording has been lost.
5. Perdido. Unlike Take the "A" Train I have a great problem in believing Clark Terry when he claimed that Billy played the piano on this piece.
8-13. The LIBERIAN SUITE. Elayne Jones' involvement with the Suite as far as playing timpani is concerned is a bit of a mystery. According to the liner-notes, Dance # 3 is supposed to be the selection on which she performed because this is the only part of the suite with a violin solo, shortly after which came her little contribution. I tried to locate the timpani after Ray Nance's part of Dance # 3, but I could not find it. The personnel listing on page 3 does not include her name and mentions Sonny Greer as having played the timpani at this recording session. Elayne made a presentation on 13Aug93 in NYC for the Ellington Conference in which she made us listen to the introduction to Dance # 1 from the 27Dec47 concert in which she played her "only note". This note could (and can) be heard after the first note on the piano by Ellington at the end of the introduction. I also checked the performance of the 26Dec47 concert. On this occasion there was so much percussion at that point that it is impossible (for me) to say if Elayne also played in the first concert or only in the second. She certainly was present during both concerts because she performed on piano in Entrance of Youth. At the end of Elayne's presentation Patricia Willard asked her if she also participated in the studio recordings on 24Dec47. Her answer was "No, she didn't". I have listened to all three studio recorded versions of Dance # 1: they are the unissued rehearsal, the released Columbia recording and the alternate on Up to Date 2005. On none of the three do I hear timpani at that moment in the performance. My guess is that she did indeed play at both concerts on Dance # 1, but that she did not play on Dance # 3 during the studio session as is suggested in the liner notes. Listening to all these performances of 24, 26 and 27Dec47 makes it difficult to believe that the studio recordings were made before the concerts.
That Dance # 5 on this release is an alternate take (as detected by Georges Debroe) went unnoticed. I wonder if Michael Brooks and Michael Cuscuna have also found the previously released version among the original acetates and if so, I would thank them for giving us collectors an alternate take to enjoy. But why not mention it?
9-10. The LIBERIAN SUITE (Dances #1 and #2).
Like many others I thought that in this era, blessed by the best technological knowledge, we could expect the world's top record companies to release faultless products. Not so. I bought a copy of the latest version of "Ellington Uptown", Columbia 512917. Reading them on the way back home, I was pleased to learn from the liner notes that at last the annoying silence between Dances No. 1 & 2, had been eliminated. This is indeed what really happens but, could somebody explain why in the process one bar, the first of Dance # 2, was cut off ? I might expect to be told that there were insuperable technical problems but this is not so. My copy of 10" LP Philips B07611R is perfectly edited. If it was impossible (why?) to do it again they could at least make a copy of a small portion of the original tapes or pressings and insert it. Can anyone check a copy of the Original American Columbia 10" LP and see if it's OK?
I also have only the Philips 10" LP and not the Columbia 10" LP. Both my CBS 12" LPs (66607L and 62686) and the CBS CD 462989 (Volume 5 of "The Complete Duke Ellington") have the same pause as you described it. It is worth checking the original Columbia release, because in the past some differences have been found between the Columbia and the Philips releases. I share your irritation about the missing bar in the latest release, but I do not share your objection concerning the pause in the 12" LPs and the earlier CD versions. Actually during the première concert at the Carnegie Hall there was not only a pause, filled with applause, but there was also an introduction by the band at the start of Dance #2 which was not on the studio releases. I do not say studio recordings, because who knows: maybe the introduction in the studio has been deleted? The original recording (as stated in the liner-notes) was certainly not made without an interruption between Dance #1 and Dance #2. Comparing the studio version (of 24Dec47) and the concerts (of 26 and 27Dec47) makes me once again express doubt that this is the correct sequence of these recordings. It sounds as if the studio recordings were made after the concerts.
Yes, in principle I wouldn't have any objection to separating the two dances. I only dislike the accidental cut in the way it has been done. Really the ending of Dance #1, being so weird, doesn't help, but that's it. Maybe the pause should be longer? Even one and a half second (that's what it is, not three seconds as mentioned in the new liner notes) are not enough to let the last note fade out naturally in your ear! I don't know. Anyway, I prefer the way it is arranged on the 10" LP!
"Masterpieces by Ellington".
I really cannot say which spelling is correct. I have Marenguito instead of Merenghito.
The date I have for the four "masterpieces" is 18Dec50 and not 19Dec50, but it is very possible that this is due to the recording session going on after midnight.
I do not have Francis Williams in the session of 11Dec51. For the session of 7Aug51, I have Cat Anderson instead of Andres Marenguito.
On 19Dec90, Mitchell Parish told the gathering of the Duke Ellington Society of NYC that he was the lyricist of Mood Indigo. In 2001 however in an article in IAJRC Journal of Winter 2001, pages 37-38, Don Peak and Tor Magnusson explained that the lyricist was Gene Austin, who was reported to have sold the lyrics for $ 25.- to Irving Mills. In either case there is no question about who got the revenues of the copyright: Irving again.
In spite of Yvonne's statement that Duke played during the whole recording of Sophisticated Lady, I believe that Luciano Massagli and Giovanni Volonté are right in stating that Billy Strayhorn took over in the 3° chorus. However I cannot buy the statement that Billy played parts of The Tattooed Bride. I only hear Ellington.
I share Patricia Willard's reservations about the statement in "some discographies" (that must have been in the New DESOR) that Billy played the beginning of Mood Indigo. I only hear Ellington. I only have some doubts in the 7° chorus.
If Eddie de Lange's name is originally Dutch it is certainly spelled de Lange and not DeLang.
The six important Columbia/Legacy re-releases with
See DEMS 03/2-21&22
The first set of three CDs has been released and has been discussed in DEMS 03/3-20/4 and 04/2-30. The numbers under which these CDs have been released in Austria are different from those, given in our listing in 03/2. What we mentioned were the American release numbers.
Festival Session in America CK 87044; in Europe 512916 2
Ellington Uptown CK 87006; 512917 2
Masterpieces by Ellington CK 87043; 512918 2
The following set of three CDs is now scheduled to be released 2Aug04:
Blues in Orbit CK 87041; 512915 2
Piano in the Background CK 87107; 512919 2
Piano in the Foreground CK 87042; 512920 2
Three Little Words
See DEMS 04/1-4
I have spent an afternoon to listen to all the solos that Freddy Jenkins played with the Ellington Orchestra and I must tell you that I changed my mind: it was certainly Freddy Jenkins and not Cootie Williams who played the solo in Three Little Words.
Duke's spoken intro on the Fairmont LP
Stan Slome has sent me as a filler on a cassette the first side of ELLINGTON '59 from Fairmont LP F107. It is the same as the ELLINGTON MOODS on SESAC LP Se N2701/02 and DUKE'S D.J. SPECIAL on FRESH SOUND FSR-CD 141.
There is a 'Spoken Introduction by Duke Ellington', which is noted both by Timner and by Nielsen. Do you know why it is ignored in the New DESOR?
I guess that it was not included in the 27Mar59 session because it was not recorded during that session. Duke spoke of recently cut in New York. He is probably not in New York when he said this and it was definitely not on 27Mar59. I think that DESOR has given up hope to find the actual recording date of this commercial. If it will be found it should be a separate session or belong to another one.
You are right. We have not mentioned the spoken intro by Duke because untill now we haven't found the actual recording date of it.
Lost Secret Records LSR-001
See DEMS 03/1-15/1
If you have not succeeded in finding this CD, you can now order it from WorldsRecords for $ 16.- under code 52022. See for address etc. DEMS 02/3-15/3
All American in Jazz
I've come across a set of five 7-inch (45RPM-sized) 33 1/3 RPM records by Duke Ellington, and I was wondering if you have any idea what they might be worth. I've searched the major record collector sites and googled all over, but I find no mention of them at all. They're on a Columbia "Stereo Seven" label, numbers S7 31433 thru 31437, packaged up in a brown jacket that says "Stereo Seven Artist of the Week", for jukeboxes only. And they're in beautiful condition.
Any info would help.
The five 7 inch LPs are well known among Ellington collectors. The music is the same as on the 12 inch LP, titled All American in Jazz, Columbia CL-1790, recorded in Jan62. The music is by Charlie Strouse and Lee Adams from a musical under the title ALL AMERICAN, arranged for the Ellington orchestra by Billy Strayhorn (8 selections) and probably Ellington (2 selections: Nightlife and What a Country!)). It is not considered one of Ellington's masterpieces. The LP is difficult to find but the music has been re-released on CD Columbia 469138-2 which is a French product and probably difficult to find in the USA.
Your set will only have value for a collector of the records itself but not for the collectors of Ellington's music. Most of them must have it already.
You could put it on sale on E-bay and ask for a bid. I have no idea about the price you will get. If there are interested DEMS members we will forward your address.
I Can't Give You Anything but Love - by the
A salesman in England has offered through E-bay a Harry Coster pressing of B12782-B, I Can't Give You Anything but Love, according to the label by the Mills Brothers and Duke Ellington. On the picture of the label one can also read: A on Br 6519. Recording date 22Dec32. This recording is not mentioned in the New DESOR. B12782 is missing. B12781 is Diga Diga Doo with the Mills Brothers and Duke Ellington and B12783 is I Can't Give You Anything but Love by Ethel Waters and Duke Ellington.
Is this an unknown recording?
It seems so, but I wouldn't count on it. In The "Wax Works" of Duke Ellington by Benny Aasland (1954) we found: "The missing matrix number, 12782, in this session is not recorded by Ellington."
The Complete Wellington Concert of 9Feb70
See DEMS 04/1-7
One of the "old" broadcasts was introduced by a male speaker who spoke of the concert of "last Monday". 9Feb70 was indeed a Monday. This "old" broadcast contained the following selections in the following sequence: C-Jam Blues; Take the "A" Train"; Passion Flower; Things Ain't What They Used To Be; Birth of the Blues; Harlem; Satin Doll and Meditation.
The second "old" broadcast contained La Plus Belle Africaine; Come Off the Veldt; a Medley with 14 selections and In Triplicate. The beginning of La Plus Belle Africaine and the end of In Triplicate are missing as described in the New DESOR for 7015d and 7015j (pp 988 and 944).
Both broadcasts were mentioned in Joe Igo's files with the indication that the first one was a delayed broadcast and the second a location recording. Although the second sounds a bit like a portable recording, it was introduced as a broadcast by a lady-speaker who clearly mentioned Town Hall and Wellington. She said that this was the last half-hour of the concert. However, the broadcast took 38 minutes.
The broadcasts of 29Apr99 contained in the following order: C-Jam Blues; Take the "A" Train; Passion Flower; Things Ain't What They Used To Be; Birth of the Blues; Harlem; La Plus Belle Africaine and Come Off the Veldt.
The broadcast of 30Apr99 contained in the following order: a Medley with the following 10 selections: Do Nothin' Till You Hear from Me, Don't Get Around Much Anymore, Mood Indigo, I'm Beginning To See the Light, Solitude, It Don't Mean a Thing, I Got It Bad, Be Cool and Groovy for Me, Sophisticated Lady and Caravan. This Medley was followed by: In Triplicate; Satin Doll; Meditation; April in Paris; April in Paris; Fife; Ocht O'Clock Rock; Satin Doll and close.
I listened to all the broadcasts and I found that the second "old" one is different when compared with the 1999 broadcast. The first "old" one however contains exactly the same recordings as the 1999 broadcasts. This means that on 9Feb70 the Duke played two concerts in Wellington. I suggest that the second "old" broadcast was possibly recorded during the afternoon concert and the 1999 broadcasts during the evening concert: I think that, unfortunately, we'll never know for certain. I would like to know your opinion before we delete the session 7015 and replace it with 2 new sessions.
About the sequence of the selections in my opinion, there is no reason to change the order of the broadcasts of Apr99 even if it might appear a little strange to see 4 encores after Meditation.
I have also listened to the broadcasts in question. It seems impossible to determine which broadcast came from the first and which came from the second concert. In both concerts, Ellington apologised to his audience for keeping them up so late. I would guess that there were two evening concerts, one after the other. This was often the case. 9Feb70 was a Monday, not a very likely day for an afternoon concert.
The so called "old" broadcast (introduced by a lady speaker) is now session 9042 on Correction-sheet 1063. The two broadcasts of Apr99 are combined as session 9043 on Correction-sheet 1064.